The Call for a Constitutional Amendment Has never been stronger to 'Get money out of politics. " Passing the wrong amendment would be disastrous 

Congress has a choice. It can give lawmakers more room to regulate campaign spending, or it can also end the corporate constitutional rights that made Citizens United possible.

Imagine fighting for years to overturn Citizens United. You organize in your community, push Congress to act, and persuade 38 states to ratify an amendment. Then a corporation goes to court and invokes its own constitutional rights to challenge a law your community fought to pass.


Sign The Congressional Leadership Letter Today - Move to Amend

 

That’s a risk if we pass an amendment that deals only with election spending. A narrower amendment could give lawmakers meaningful power to rein in big money in elections. It could also leave corporations with constitutional claims they can use against public-interest laws. If Congress asks the country to do the work of amending the Constitution, we should demand language that addresses both problems. National Archives

The problem started long before Citizens United

In 2010, the Supreme Court struck down federal restrictions on corporations and unions using their treasury funds for independent election spending. The Court treated those restrictions as a violation of the First Amendment. That decision built on decades of case law, including Buckley v. Valeo, the 1976 ruling that struck down several campaign spending limits while upholding limits on direct contributions to candidates. 

Corporate constitutional rights reach well beyond elections. In Marshall v. Barlow’s, Inc., a company refused to let a federal workplace safety inspector enter without a warrant. The Supreme Court held that the Fourth Amendment generally required a warrant for that kind of inspection. That was in 1978, more than three decades before Citizens United. An amendment confined to campaign finance would leave that ruling in place. Workers have a stake in this debate even when there’s no election on the calendar. Justia U.S. Supreme Court Center

Learn more at Corporate Constitutional Rights Resources - Move To Amend

Permission to regulate is only part of the job

Take two proposals before Congress. The Democracy for All Amendment, H.J.Res. 121, would let Congress and the states set reasonable election spending limits, including prohibiting spending by corporations and other artificial entities. H.J.Res. 191 would also give lawmakers room to regulate contributions and spending and to prohibit artificial entities from raising or spending money in covered elections and ballot measure campaigns. Those are meaningful powers. Under either proposal, lawmakers would still get to decide whether to use them, and corporations could still invoke constitutional rights in disputes outside campaign finance. 

That difference matters. The same lawmakers who benefit from the current system would be asked to decide whether to curb it. And after years of organizing, Congress could declare the problem solved while communities were still fighting corporate constitutional claims one case at a time. It takes two-thirds of both houses of Congress to send an amendment to the states and three-fourths of the states to ratify it. The time to insist on language that meets the scale of the problem is before Congress takes that vote. 

Watch for Trojan horse amendments

Be wary when billionaires and corporate interests start championing an amendment to “get money out of politics.” They have a stake in the wording, and so do we. A proposal can promise to overturn Citizens United while preserving the constitutional rights corporations use to challenge laws that protect workers and communities. It can give Congress permission to limit election spending while leaving lawmakers free to do nothing. That’s the Trojan horse: a reform that sounds sweeping until you read what it actually requires.

Read the text. Who holds constitutional rights? Can courts still treat spending to influence elections as protected speech? Does the amendment say lawmakers may regulate or that they shall act? Read what comes after “shall.” An amendment can say lawmakers shall have the power to rein in election spending and still leave them free to sit on their hands. That’s the kind of Trojan horse we should watch for when oligarchs and corporate interests line up behind a proposal to “get money out of politics.” Look at what the text actually requires and which corporate powers it leaves intact. The We the People Amendment makes regulating election money a constitutional duty and ends corporate constitutional rights. Both belong in the amendment we fight to pass. These are the questions to ask before anyone gets to claim victory. Oligarchs can afford to spend years fighting over a loophole. The rest of us have every reason to close it before it goes into the Constitution.

Why Move to Amend supports H.J.Res. 54

The We the People Amendment, introduced by Rep. Pramila Jayapal as H.J.Res. 54, addresses who holds constitutional rights and how money in elections is governed. Its provisions work together. 

  • Constitutional rights belong to human beings. Corporations, LLCs, and other artificial entities would have the privileges that federal, state, and local law provide. They could still own property, enter contracts, and operate under the law. People would retain their constitutional rights to speak and organize together, and the amendment expressly safeguards freedom of the press. 
  • Spending money to influence elections is not speech under the First Amendment. H.J.Res. 54 tells courts directly how to treat that spending. This matters because concentrated wealth can buy disproportionate political influence whether it comes from a corporate treasury or a wealthy individual’s bank account. 
  • Federal, state, and local governments shall act. The amendment requires governments to regulate, limit, or prohibit contributions and expenditures, including candidates’ own spending, with the goal of ensuring access to the political process regardless of wealth. It also requires public disclosure of contributions and expenditures that are allowed. “Shall” makes action a constitutional duty. 

When a member of Congress says they support overturning Citizens United, ask which amendment they support. Ask whether it ends corporate constitutional rights, whether it stops courts from treating election spending as protected speech, and whether it requires lawmakers to act. Their answers tell you what they’re prepared to change.

We have a chance to build a democracy where a worker, a tenant, or a parent can have a meaningful say in the decisions that shape their lives, regardless of how much money they have. Congress should hold hearings on the We the People Amendment in the first 100 days of the new Congress and bring it to the floor for a vote.

 


Help Move to Amend make sure Congress gets this right.

When lawmakers say they want to overturn Citizens United, someone has to read the fine print, show the public what’s at stake, and press Congress to act.

That’s what Move to Amend does. 

Your donation helps us analyze competing amendments, train grassroots advocates, and meet with lawmakers to make the case for the We the People Amendment.

Donate to Move to Amend

and help us demand an amendment that ends corporate constitutional rights and requires governments to regulate money in elections.

Sign Move to Amend’s petition,

share this article, and ask your representative to support H.J.Res. 54.

Katie Krasinski

About

Katie Krasinski is National Co-Director of Move to Amend, where she helps build the movement to end corporate constitutional rights and the influence of big money in politics. Her work spans fundraising, communications, volunteer engagement, and grassroot
Share this post: Facebook X / Twitter LinkedIn Email